Home
>
Diet and Nutrition
> Nutritional
Requirements of CKD Cats
Overview
-
This page starts with a brief overview of the physiological needs of cats
generally.
-
It then examines
the nutritional requirements of CKD cats in particular, and includes a
discussion of the reduced protein debate.
-
It also discusses other nutritional issues, such as
the importance of weight and muscle maintenance.
Physiological Needs of Cats
Cats are not small dogs. They have unique physiological
needs. When you are dealing with CKD, you need to meet these basic needs but
also cater as far as possible for their CKD-related needs.
Basic Physiological Needs
There are many different opinions about
the best food for cats, and the debate can get quite heated. I don't wish
to focus on that here, but rather to explain the basic needs of cats from
a scientific perspective.
Cats are obligate carnivores. This does
not mean they can only eat meat. It means that, unlike other species, such
as humans and dogs, they cannot manufacture certain amino acids
essential to life themselves. In order to obtain these amino acids, they must eat
food which contains them, and ideally that means they must eat meat,
though they may also be able to obtain them from other sources (for
example, corn
gluten meal, the protein part of corn, actually contains all the amino
acids which cats need).
It is a myth that our domestic cats are
miniature versions of the big cats such as lions. Big cats are part of a
pride, and hunt together. Domestic cats, in contrast, are solitary
predators, and if they are living in their own version of the wild, they
only eat what they can catch. They catch mice, insects, whatever passes by
or what they can hunt. This means they have evolved to eat little and
often. They eat very little plant material or carbohydrate, only what
would be found in a mouse's stomach, though they may sometimes also eat
small amounts of grass.
Originally cats were desert animals, so
they evolved to not want to drink much. Since a mouse is approximately 60%
water, historically this was not an issue — they obtained sufficient fluid
intake from their food. Therefore ideally cats also need to eat foods
containing a reasonable amount of water.
In a study in which cats were not allowed to choose
how much they ate, but were able to select the nutrient mix that they
preferred,
Geometric analysis of macronutrient selection in the
adult domestic cat, Felis catus
(2011) Hewson-Hughes AK, Hewson-Hughes VL, Miller AT, Hall SR, Simpson SJ
& Raubenheimer D Journal of Experimental Biology 214
pp1039-1051 found that "the intake target lies close to 26g day protein,
9g day fat and 8g day carbohydrate, yielding a macronutrient energy
composition of 52% protein, 36% fat and 12% carbohydrate."
So to summarise, healthy cats need
foods containing a large percentage of meat-based protein, with limited
vegetables and grains. They need to eat little and often, and ideally a
wet food containing around 60% moisture; but the ingredients are more
important.
The feeding behavior of the cat
(2010) Horwitz D, Soulard Y & Junien-Castagna A Encyclopaedia of Feline
Nutrition pp439-477 is an excellent overview of feline eating habits.
AAFP consensus statement; feline feeding programs:
addressing behavioural needs to improve feline health and wellbeing
(2018) Sadek T, Hamper B, Horwitz D, Rodan I, Rowe E & Sundahl E
Journal of Feline Medicine and Surgery 20(11) pp1049-1055
discusses feline feeding needs.
Physiological Needs of CKD Cats
It becomes a little more complicated when you add CKD
to the mix. You still want to feed a diet that meets your cat's basic
physiological needs, as outlined above, but if possible you also want to
feed a diet that can help with the CKD.
There are two main concerns with diet in CKD cats:
-
It is essential to keep your cat eating, and to maintain weight and muscle
as much as possible.
-
Ideally you do not want to feed anything that may make the disease
progress faster and/or make the cat feel poorly.
Below I discuss the importance of weight management and calorie intake in CKD cats,
followed by an explanation of the main components of the feline diet, such as protein
and phosphorus, and how they impact on CKD. The protein section includes
information about the pros and cons of a reduced protein diet.
I recommend that ideally you read this page so you can
understand the main components of feline diets. Then you can read the
Which Foods to Feed
page, which discusses food choices including therapeutic kidney diets, and what to do if
your cat refuses to eat them.
Remember, the most important thing is that
your cat eats. I cannot emphasise this enough. If you're struggling to get
any food at all into your cat, check out the
Persuading Your Cat
To Eat page.
Weight and Muscle
Maintaining weight and muscle is extremely important.
Anorexic cats (cats who have stopped eating) and cachexic cats (cats who
have lost a lot of muscle) have a worse prognosis than cats of a normal
weight, so it is essential to monitor your cat's weight and body condition
closely, and above all to keep your cat eating.
Staged management of chronic kidney disease in dogs
and cats (2009) Polzin D Presentation to the
World Small Animal Veterinary Association World Congress
says: "Ideally patients should consume sufficient calories from an
appropriate diet to maintain a body condition score of 4 to 5/9. Increased
efforts are indicated to assure sufficient calorie intake for patients
with body condition scores of 3/9 or lower or when patients fail to
consume adequate calories to maintain a stable, appropriate body weight."
The World Small Animal Veterinary Association
has a body condition score chart showing how to gauge your cat's physical
condition,.
Purina has a guide to hoe to use a
body condition score.
If you are lucky enough to have a slightly overweight CKD cat,
rejoice, and personally I would not put him or her on a diet, because as the CKD
progresses, your cat will almost certainly lose weight anyway.
Weight
Older cats (over the age of ten) are prone to weight
loss, even if they have no underlying health problems.
It is not known exactly why older cats lose weight, but
it is thought it may be at least in part because
their bodies become less able to digest nutrients, particularly fat and
protein.
Skinny old cats: why some senior cats lose weight. What's going
on?
(2014) Williams D
DVM360
Magazine states
"The incidence of low fat digestibility
increases with age, affecting 10% to 15% of mature cats (8 to 12 years
old) and 30% of geriatric cats (> 12 years old). In some geriatric cats,
fat digestibility was found to be as low as 30%, and the only clinical
signs were large stools (not frank diarrhea) and low body weight. Low
protein digestibility also seems to affect mature and geriatric cats.
Although the incidence of low protein digestibility is lower than that of
fat digestibility, about 20% of cats older than 14 years show protein
digestibility lower than 77%. The incidence of low fat and protein
digestibility tends to occur in the same cats. A marked decline apparently
becomes particularly prevalent after around age 10."
Whatever the precise reason, weight loss in older cats is not good news.
Determining protein requirements —nitrogen balance
versus lean body mass (2013)
Laflamme DP Nestlé Purina Companion Animal Nutrition Summit Tackling
Myths About Pet Nutrition pp42-45 states "Previous research suggests
that unexplained weight loss, especially in geriatric cats, can be the
first sign of an impending terminal condition."
Effect of nutritional interventions on longevity in
senior cats (2007) Cupp CJ, Jean-Philippe C, Kerr WW, Patil AR &
Perez-Camargo G The International Journal of Applied Research in
Veterinary Medicine 5(3) says "there is evidence that extreme
leanness in old cats may actually be detrimental. Emaciated cats had a
significantly higher risk of death compared with cats in optimal body
condition. Perez-Camargo et al demonstrated that body weight, lean body
mass, and fat mass decline in cats over the age of 12 years, particularly
in the last 1 to 2 years of life."
Even in younger cats, low body weight can be a concern.
Strong associations of 9-point body condition
scoring with survival and lifespan in cats
(2018) Teng KT, McGreevy PD, Toribio JL, Raubenheimer D, Kendall K
& Dhand NK Journal of Feline Medicine and Surgery 20 epub
looked at over 2600 cats and found that cats with a body condition score
of 4 or 5 between the ages of 1 and 3, and a maximum body condition score
of 3 between the ages of 3 and 11 had a shorter lifespan than cats with a
body condition score of 6. The study concludes "There are significant
associations of 9-point body condition scoring with survival and lifespan,
and BCSs <5 and of 9 were found to be negatively associated with both."
As far as CKD goes,
Risk factors associated with the development of
chronic kidney disease in cats evaluated at primary care veterinary
hospitals (2014) Greene JP, Lefebvre SL, Wang M, Yang M,
Lund EM & Polzin DJ Journal of the American Veterinary Medical
Association 244(3) pp320-327 found that median weight loss in
CKD cats in the 6-12 months before diagnosis was 10.8%, which was a lot
higher than in cats who did not develop CKD.
Evaluation of weight loss over time in cats with
chronic kidney disease (2016)
Freeman LM, Lachaud M-P, Matthews S, Rhodes L & Zollers B Journal of
Veterinary Internal Medicine 30(5) pp1661–1666 found that
"weight loss was already present 3 years before diagnosis and accelerated
after diagnosis of CKD. Cats <4.2 kg at the time of diagnosis had
significantly shorter survival time compared to cats ≥ 4.2 kg at
diagnosis."
Weight loss in CKD happens partly because many CKD cats have poor appetites, but CKD cats also lose
weight because of the disease.
Mechanisms causing loss of lean body mass in kidney disease
(1999) Mitch WE The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 67
pp359-66 explains more about this problem in humans.
Prolonging life and kidney function
(2009) Chew DJ & DiBartola SP CVC in
Kansas City Proceedings states
"Maintenance of stable body weight and serum albumin concentration
suggests adequate intake of calories and protein whereas progressive
declines in body weight and serum albumin concentration suggest
malnutrition or progression of disease and are indications to increase the
amount of protein fed."
It is therefore extremely important to monitor your cat's weight and to
keep him or her eating. I recommend weighing your cat at least weekly.
There are links on buying scales suitable for weighing cats
here.
Feline weight loss
(2011) Scherck M
NAVC Clinician's Brief Nov 2011 pp18-19 has a diagnostic tree
to help narrow down the cause of weight loss in a cat.
Muscle
Muscle wasting, or cachexia, is also common in CKD cats. This is
partly because most CKD cats are elderly and the elderly are prone to
sarcopaenia, which is the age-related loss of muscle.
CKD cats may also
suffer from cachexia for other reasons.
Cachexia versus sarcopenia
(2011) Rolland Y, Abellan van Kan G, Gillette-Guyonnet S
& Vellas B Current Opinion in Clinical Nutrition and Metabolic Care
14(1) pp15-21 states "Sarcopenia is now recognized as a
multifactorial geriatric syndrome. Cachexia is defined as a metabolic
syndrome in which inflammation is the key feature and so cachexia can be
an underlying condition of sarcopenia. Recently, cachexia has been defined
as 'a complex metabolic syndrome associated with underlying illness and
characterized by loss of muscle mass with or without loss of fat mass. The
prominent clinical feature of cachexia is weight loss in adults."
CKD is one such underlying illness.
Review of muscle wasting associated with chronic
kidney disease (2010) Workeneh BT & Mitch WE American
Journal of Clinical Nutrition 91(4) pp1128S-1132S states that
muscle wasting is common in human CKD patients, particularly those with
inflammation or
metabolic acidosis.
Cachexia and sarcopenia: emerging syndromes of
importance in dogs and cats (2012) Freeman LM Journal of
Veterinary Internal Medicine 26 pp3-17 says "The syndrome of
cachexia also appears to be common in companion animals with chronic
diseases, such as CHF, CKD, and cancer." Cachexia must be taken seriously.
Dr Freeman goes on to say "The prevalence of cachexia in people with CKD
is estimated to be 20%. Although the prevalence of cachexia in dogs and
cats with CKD has not specifically been measured, it appears to be
relatively high and likely has negative clinical effects."
Since
creatinine,
one of the measures of kidney function, is a by-product of muscle, cats who lose a lot of muscle may
have reduced creatinine levels, because they cannot produce as much
creatinine.
The Merck Veterinary Manual states "Serum
creatinine levels can be falsely lowered in patients with severe muscle
wasting."
Feeding cats with different nutritional needs: a
dilemma in the multicat household (2012) Scherk M
Presentation to the 73rd SCIVAC International Congress 2012 pp421-430
states "As
an obligate carnivore, if a cat doesn’t get enough dietary protein to meet
metabolic requirements, he must draw on endogenous (stored) protein
sources to meet those needs. Over months cats can down regulate their
protein needs and switch to use other pathways, but in the short and
intermediate term, muscle will be catabolized. The resulting muscle
wasting and decreased mass reduces the serum level of creatinine (Cr)
measured."
You may therefore think your cat's CKD is improving
because the creatinine is falling, when in fact this is not the case.
Cats with
hyperthyroidism also tend to lose a lot of muscle, which is an additional
headache if your cat has both CKD and hyperthyroidism.
Dietary omega-3 fatty acid
supplementation increases the rate of muscle protein synthesis in older
adults: a randomized controlled trial
(2011) Smith GI, Atherton P, Reeds DN, Mohammed BS, Rankin D, Rennie MJ,
Mittendorfer B American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 93(2)
pp402-12 investigated the effects of essential fatty acids (see
below) on loss of muscle mass in
healthy older human adults (sarcopaenia). It concluded "Omega-3 fatty
acids stimulate muscle protein synthesis in older adults and may be useful
for the prevention and treatment of sarcopenia."
The World Small Animal Veterinary Association
has a muscle condition score chart.
Calories
When considering a food for their CKD cats, many people focus on its phosphorus and
protein levels,
but it is also important to consider the calorie content, especially if
you want your cat to maintain or gain weight and muscle.
A healthy cat needs
approximately 30-35 calories per day per pound of body weight, or possibly
more if the cat is particularly active.
Your cat's nutritional needs
(2006) National Research Council states that a lean
adult cat weighing 5 lbs needs around 170 calories a day, and a lean adult
cat weighing 10 pounds needs around 280 calories a day.
The World Small Animal Veterinary Association
Nutritional Assessment Guidelines make similar recommendations for the
average healthy adult cat at a healthy weight.
This level of intake is unlikely to be sufficient for older
cats. In
Feeding older cats - an update in new nutritional therapies
(2011) Sparkes A Topics in Companion Animal Medicine
26(1) pp37-42, Dr Sparkes states that older cats need more calories
than younger cats, preferably in the form of protein. He adds that older
cats also seem to do better when fed a diet containing
prebiotics,
antioxidants and
essential fatty acids. Many sources, including the
National Research Council, also believe that chronically sick cats need
more calories, possibly as many as twice the number of calories as healthy
cats.
Feline CKD therapeutic goals: do not throw away your
shot (2018) Wooten SJ DVM360 Magazine reports "The most
important thing to ponder about nutrition in feline CKD is whether the cat
is eating enough, Dr. St. Denis says. This is more important than what the
cat is eating. Maintaining adequate caloric intake and muscle mass is
critical to avoid protein malnutrition. But, as you already know, ensuring
adequate intake in a cat can be very challenging. Working with the client
and providing education in this area is an important therapeutic strategy.
If the cat isn't eating enough or is underweight, then Dr. St. Denis
recommends feeding 1.2 to 1.4 times the resting energy requirement (RER).
Most geriatric cats need at least 1.1 times RER."
So obviously, feeding a teaspoonful of food a day is not going to be
enough to maintain your CKD cat's weight, let alone increase it if your
cat is too thin. Another thing to consider is the water content of the
food. Whilst most canned foods contain around 80% water, some are as high as 85% water. Although increased fluid content can
be helpful for CKD cats, who are at risk of dehydration, the downside is
that such foods may make the cat feel relatively full while providing
insufficient calories for the cat's needs. This is often the case with
simple foods that consist largely of meat or fish. Lower fat foods may
also contain fewer calories.
As far as CKD is concerned, the goal is, as AJ Fascetti & S Delaney from
the University of California at Davis say in
Nutritional management of chronic renal disease,
"Your pet needs to consume sufficient calories to supply essential
nutrients, as well as to prevent the breakdown of their body's protein
stores that will cause malnutrition and exacerbate the clinical signs of
uremia."
ISFM consensus guidelines on the diagnosis and
management of feline chronic kidney disease (2016)
Sparkes AH, Caney S, Chalhoub S, Elliott J, Finch N, Gajanayake I,
Langston C, Lefebvre H, White J & Quimby J Journal of Feline Medicine &
Surgery 18 pp219-239 state "maintaining calorie intake is the
highest priority in CKD."
Therapeutic kidney diets are more calorie dense than standard maintenance
diets.
You can check
the calorie content of some US foods
here (canned) and
here (dry).
Diagnostic and therapeutic approach to the anorectic
cat
(2001) Marks S Presentation to the World Small Animal Veterinary
Association World Congress 2001 discusses feline dietary and calorie
needs.
The ins and outs of managing feline chronic kidney
disease Codi M Today's
Veterinary Technician has a formula (Box 1) for calculating the daily
energy requirement for neutered CKD cats.
Metabolisable Energy
Some manufacturers provide data about the metabolisable
energy (ME) of their foods.
ME is the amount of energy available from a food for your cat to use once
your cat has digested the food.
Metabolizable energy and caloric density
by PetCoach explains how foods vary in terms of the
number of calories which are actually available to a cat after digestion:
"Pet foods with higher ME numbers provide your pet's body with more
concentrated calories for more energy. With a higher ME, your pet's body
will receive more energy from a smaller amount of food."
ME figures focus on protein, fat and carbohydrate.
Since phosphorus is the most important value for CKD cats, I do not look
at ME values when calculating my food data tables, but they may be useful
for people with diabetic cats,
who often look to feed foods with an ME value for carbohydrates of 10-12%
or lower.
Food
Composition and Requirements
The usual guidelines for CKD cats are to feed a diet
which has added potassium and essential fatty acids but which has reduced
levels of protein, phosphorus and
sodium. It is helpful to understand the reasoning behind these
recommendations.
Protein
If you asked most people what was the main nutritional step to take for a
cat with kidney disease, they would probably say "feed low protein."
However, it's not quite as simple as that. This section discusses the role
of protein in kidney disease and if and when to reduce the levels of
protein which you feed.
What is Protein?
Protein is a molecular structure made up of a number of
amino acids which are essential for the body to repair and maintain
itself.
Cats have a higher need for protein than many other
species because, unlike dogs or humans, they cannot manufacture certain of
these amino acids (e.g. taurine) within their bodies but instead have to
obtain them from their food. These missing amino acids are only found in
meat (and corn gluten meal), and therefore cats must ideally eat meat in
order to obtain these amino acids. This is why cats are known as obligate
carnivores. When people feed a cat a vegetarian diet (which I definitely
do not recommend for any cat), they provide these amino acids in the form
of supplements, but cats are optimally designed to obtain them from meat.
Feline Protein
Requirements
Determining protein requirements — nitrogen balance
versus lean body mass (2013)
Laflamme DP Nestlé Purina Companion Animal Nutrition Summit Tackling
Myths About Pet Nutrition pp42-45 states "The current recommendation by
AAFCO for protein in adult cat foods is 26% of the diet dry matter or 65g
protein/1000Kcal metabolizable energy. Assuming an average calorie intake of
60Kcal ME/kg body weight for adult cats, this would equate to approximately
3.9g protein/kg body weight. The National Research Council (NRC) guidelines
indicate a minimum daily protein requirement and a recommended daily protein
allowance of 2.5 and 3.13g protein/kg body weight, respectively."
Let's crunch some numbers based on these recommendations:
-
the AAFCO recommendations would mean that a healthy 10lb (4.5kg)
adult cat would need a minimum of 18g of protein a day.
-
the NRC guidelines would mean that a
healthy 10lb (4.5kg) adult cat would need a minimum of 11.4g but a recommended level of
14g of protein a day.
These levels sounded low to me, and research indicates
they probably are.
Discrepancy between use of lean body mass or
nitrogen balance to determine protein requirements for adult cats
(2014) Laflamme DP & Hannah SS Journal of Feline Medicine & Surgery
15(8) pp691-7 examined the effects of diets with differing protein
levels. The cats in the study were fed a diet containing 34% protein for one
month, then they were divided into three groups for a further two months and
these groups were fed 20% protein, 26% protein and 34% protein respectively.
The study states that "approximately
1.5 g protein/kg (2.1 g/kg(0.75)) body weight is needed to maintain nitrogen
balance, while 5.2 g protein/kg (7.8 g/kg(0.75)) body weight is needed to
maintain LBM [lean body mass, i.e. muscle]. This study provides evidence
that nitrogen balance studies are inadequate for determining optimum protein
requirements. Animals, including cats, can adapt to low protein intake and
maintain nitrogen balance while depleting LBM. Loss of LBM and an associated
reduction in protein turnover can result in compromised immune function and
increased morbidity. Current Association of American Feed Control Officials
(AAFCO) and National Research Council (NRC) standards for protein adequacy
may not provide adequate protein to support LBM. The minimum daily protein
requirement for adult cats appears to be at least 5.2 g/kg (7.8 g/kg(0.75))
body weight, well in excess of current AAFCO and NRC recommendations.
Further research is needed to determine the effect, if any, of body
condition, age and gender on protein requirements."
On this basis, a 10lb (4.5kg) cat would need a protein
intake of 23.6g per day. In a study in which cats were not allowed to choose
how much they ate, but were able to select the nutrient mix that they
preferred,
Geometric analysis of macronutrient selection in the
adult domestic cat, Felis catus
(2011) Hewson-Hughes AK, Hewson-Hughes VL, Miller AT, Hall
SR, Simpson SJ & Raubenheimer D Journal of Experimental Biology
214 pp1039-1051 found that in fact for the average cat, "the intake
target lies close to 26g day protein..., yielding a macronutrient energy
composition of 52% protein." Based on the size of the cats in that study,
that actually translated to 5.3g/kg, so very close to the Laflamme
calculations above.
To complicate matters, older cats may have higher protein requirements.
Skinny old cats: why some senior cats lose weight. What's going
on?
(2014) Williams D DVM360
Magazine
states "Low protein digestibility also seems to affect
mature and geriatric cats. Although the incidence of low protein
digestibility is lower than that of fat digestibility, about 20% of cats
older than 14 years show protein digestibility lower than 77%." In
Feeding old cats - an update in new nutritional
therapies (2011) Sparkes A Topics in Companion Animal Medicine
26(1) pp37-42, Dr Sparkes states that older cats need more calories
than younger cats, preferably in the form of protein. He adds that older
cats also seem to do better when fed a diet containing
prebiotics, antioxidants and
essential fatty
acids.
PetCoach has an overview of protein
requirements in cats.
Early Research into Reduced Protein for CKD
Cats
Studies performed on humans and rats with CKD found that feeding reduced
levels of protein appeared to be beneficial and might help prolong life. Therefore researchers wondered if
a lower
protein intake might have a similar beneficial effect for cats.
In many of the early studies in cats, the
cats had a large percentage of their kidneys
surgically removed in order to induce kidney failure; this is not the way
kidney disease tends to develop in most cats, who usually have chronic
kidney disease rather than acute kidney injury. Even so, the results were
not necessarily what might have been expected. In
Effects of dietary protein and calorie restriction in
clinically normal cats and in cats with surgically induced chronic renal
failure (1993) Adams LG Polzin DJ Osborne CA & O'Brien TD
American Journal of Veterinary Research 54 pp1653-1662, CKD
cats were fed either a 38% DMA protein diet or a much reduced (20% DMA) protein diet for one year.
The cats fed the 38% protein diet had higher
BUN levels (as might be
expected) than the cats fed the low protein diet (who were fed 2.7g/kg per
day) but they also had lower
creatinine levels; and they also ate more and
gained weight compared to the cats on the low protein diet, some of whom
showed signs of malnutrition towards the end of the study. Some of the
cats fed the high protein diet did develop transient hypokalaemia (low
potassium levels), which might have been because the low protein diet
contained more potassium.
In
Protein and calorie effects on progression of induced chronic renal failure
in cats (1998) Finco DR, Brown SA, Brown CA, Crowell WA, Sunvold
G & Cooper TL American Journal of Veterinary Research 59
pp575-582, cats were divided into four groups: low protein, low calorie
(A); low protein, high calorie (B); high protein, low calorie (C); and
high calorie, high protein (D). No real differences were seen after a
year, and there was no change in GFR in any group. A vet from Ohio State
University College of Veterinary Medicine stated with regard to this
study "recent findings in cats with induced renal insufficiency suggest
that feeding diets restricted in protein may not be necessary for this
species. Cats fed 9g of protein per kg of bodyweight per day had no more
severe kidney lesions or lower GFR than did cats fed 5.2g of protein per
kg of bodyweight per day." In
Effects
of dietary protein intake on renal functions
(1999)
Supplement to Compendium on Continuing Education for the Practising
Veterinarian 21 Dr Finco stated "the negative results from the
second study indicate that protein restriction in cats with renal disease
remains to be proven as an effective maneuver for ameliorating progression
of renal disease."
The Upsides of Reduced Protein for CKD
Cats
These studies seem to indicate that a reduced protein intake is not
necessarily of any real benefit to CKD cats. However, there are also some studies into the use of
therapeutic kidney diets, which have
reduced protein levels rather than extremely low protein levels (along
with other attributes); and more sensibly, research began to focus on cats
with naturally occurring CKD. In
Survival of cats with naturally occurring chronic renal failure: effect of
dietary management (2000) Elliott J, Rawlings JM, Markwell
PJ, Barber PJ Journal of Small Animal Practice 41 pp235-42,
29 cats were fed a reduced protein, reduced phosphorus therapeutic kidney diet, while a
further 21 cats did not eat the therapeutic kidney diet. Some of the cats
(presumably in both groups) were also given phosphorus binders. The cats
fed the therapeutic kidney diet survived longer than the other cats, but it is
not clear whether this was due to the reduction in phosphorus intake
rather than the reduction in protein intake. The study concluded "Feeding
a veterinary clinical diet (with intestinal phosphate binders where
necessary) specifically formulated for feline renal failure was associated
with a highly significant beneficial effect on survival of cats presenting
with naturally occurring stable CKD. This is the first prospective dietary
study involving naturally occurring feline CKD cases where survival from
first diagnosis has been assessed."
The studies described above were focusing on whether a reduced protein intake might slow
the progression of kidney disease and help the cat live longer. The other
issue is whether feeding reduced protein might help the cat feel better.
The study that most experts cite when recommending a
therapeutic kidney diet is
Clinical evaluation of dietary modification for treatment of spontaneous
chronic kidney disease in cats (2006)
Ross SJ, Osborne CA, Kirk CA, Lowry SR, Koehler LA, Polzin DJ Journal
of the American Veterinary Medical Association 229(6) pp949-57.
This study found that feeding a therapeutic kidney diet helped to keep
BUN levels lower and appeared to
help prevent
metabolic
acidosis in cats with more advanced CKD. The study concluded "The
renal diet evaluated in this study [Hill's k/d] was superior to an adult
maintenance diet in minimizing uremic episodes and renal-related deaths in
cats with spontaneous stage 2 or 3 CKD [creatinine between 2.1 and 4.5 mg/dl
or 165 - 400
µmol/L international]."
Thus in this study the therapeutic kidney diet not only
appeared to reduce the number of deaths, but the cats also exhibited fewer
signs of illness. This is because, during the breakdown of
dietary protein in the digestive process, waste substances are created
which are filtered out of the blood by the kidneys and excreted via
urination. This is sometimes referred to as the removal of nitrogenous
wastes. Unfortunately damaged kidneys find it harder to do this, which is
why BUN levels rise in CKD.
Contrary to popular opinion, BUN and creatinine are not toxins themselves.
However, BUN levels correlate with uraemic toxin levels, i.e. if BUN is
elevated, it is highly likely that toxins are also elevated, and you will
usually see various signs of sickness which collectively are
known as
uraemia.
If you feed a reduced protein diet, this reduces the amount of nitrogenous wastes that
must be processed by the kidneys. This usually leads to a reduction in
BUN
levels and in turn the cat will often feel and act better. AJ Fascetti & S
Delaney from the University of California at Davis say in
Nutritional management of chronic renal disease
"Many of the clinical signs that you see in your animal such as vomiting,
lethargy, anorexia, diarrhea, oral ulcerations and the foul ammonia odor
to their breath can be partially or completely alleviated by reducing the
protein concentration in your animal's diet. These clinical signs, that
are often referred to as uremia, can be caused by an accumulation of the
breakdown products of protein metabolism (sometimes referred to as
nitrogenous waste products). This protein comes from both the protein in
your animal's diet, as well as mobilization and degradation of their own
body's protein stores. Consumption of protein in amounts greater than what
your animal needs to maintain normal bodily functions can exacerbate these
clinical signs."
Nutritional management of chronic renal disease
Fascetti AJ & Delaney S also says "A reduction in dietary protein may also
help reduce the degree of
anemia in some patients. Anemia enhances the weakness and reluctance
to eat in animals with renal failure. Anemia can occur for several reasons
with renal disease, but one factor that is believed to make it worse is
excessive dietary protein. Nitrogenous waste products are believed to
contribute to anemia by reducing the life span of red blood cells. The
waste products may also enhance blood loss by leading to the formation of
gastrointestinal ulcers and a reduction in blood clotting ability."
It must also be remembered that when vets recommend therapeutic kidney
diets, they are not only recommending reduced protein levels. Therapeutic
kidney diets have other attributes, for example reduced protein
diets also tend to contain less phosphorus, and phosphorus control is
extremely important in CKD cats. These foods also contain additional
levels of potassium and essential fatty acids (see below). You can read more about the attributes of therapeutic kidney diets on the
Which
Foods to Feed page.
The Downsides of Reduced
Protein for CKD Cats
Of course, nothing is ever simple when it comes to cats, so there are also
potential downsides with reduced protein intake.
One common problem with reduced protein for cats, as you might expect, is
weight loss. One study using healthy cats,
Determining protein requirements — nitrogen balance
versus lean body mass (2013)
Laflamme DP Nestlé Purina Companion Animal Nutrition Summit Tackling
Myths About Pet Nutrition pp42-45 states "Cats fed lowprotein diets
tended to lose body weight to a greater degree than those fed higher
protein diets despite no significant differences in energy intake. In
study three, for example, only the group fed the highest protein diet had
no cats removed owing to weight loss of >10%. In study one, percent weight
loss increased in a linear manner with decreasing protein intake."
Feeding cats with different nutritional needs: a
dilemma in the multicat household (2012) Scherk M
Presentation to the 73rd SCIVAC International Congress 2012 says "Protein:calorie malnutrition
occurs when a cat is getting enough calories but not enough of them come
from protein. As a result, there may or may not be weight loss, but there
will be muscle wasting as well as a deterioration in the hair coat
quality. Because protein is component in antibodies, immune function may
be compromised; anemia may be exacerbated due to the lack of building
blocks for hemoglobin; albumin levels may decrease and tissue healing will
be affected. Protein is a preferred flavour, so if a cat is already
inappetant, restricting protein may result in inadequate intake of all
nutrients, and the protein intake may fall below that required for normal
function."
Slowing the progression of chronic renal failure
(2004) Grauer GF states "There are, however, potential undesirable
effects associated with dietary protein reduction. Specifically, if
dietary protein is restricted in relation to the animal’s protein needs,
reduced renal hemodynamics, protein depletion (decreased body weight,
muscle mass, and serum albumin concentration), anemia, and acidosis can
occur or be aggravated."
Nutritional management of chronic renal disease
Fascetti AJ & Delaney S goes further, and says "not enough protein in the
diet can be equally detrimental and protein malnutrition in patients with
renal failure can facilitate the occurrence of other complications or lead
to an early death."
Cats with IRIS stage 1 and 2 chronic kidney disease
maintain body weight and lean muscle mass when fed food having increased
caloric density, and enhanced concentrations of carnitine and essential
amino acids (2019) Hall JA,
Fritsch DA, Jewell DE, Burris PA & Gross KL Veterinary Record
184(6) pp190 compared two dry therapeutic kidney diets (Hill's
Prescription Diet k/d with chicken and Royal Canin Renal Support A) fed to
cats in IRIS stage 1 or 2. The Hill's food has around 34% protein on a DMA
basis whilst the Royal Canin A has around 24%. Cats fed the Hill's food
ate more calories, maintained or increased body weight and their kidney
bloodwork remained stable, whereas the cats fed the lower protein Royal
Canin food lost weight and their creatinine levels rose more quickly.
(Most of the researchers who participated in this study work for Hill's). However,
the Hill's food was enhanced with essential amino acids, L-carnitine and
palatability, which would not be the case if you simply bought this food
as a consumer. The study did state that both diets would have provided
sufficient amino acid intake if sufficient food and calories were
consumed.
Reduced protein diets are also of concern for cats with
metabolic acidosis, because, according to
Nutrition and renal function in cats and dogs: acid-base, electrolytes and
renal failure (1999) Polzin DJ, Osborne CA, James K
Supplement to Compendium on Continuing Education for the Practising
Veterinarian 21 11(K), studies of rats and humans with renal
failure show that "acidosis may limit the ability of patients to adapt to
dietary protein restrictions." It is not yet certain whether acidosis also
affects cats in this way, but it seems plausible, given the cat's
relatively high requirement for protein.
Your Protein Goal: Sufficient, High
Quality Protein
As discussed previously, during the breakdown of dietary protein in the digestive process,
waste substances are created which are filtered out of
the blood by the kidneys and excreted via
urination. This is sometimes referred to as the removal of
nitrogenous wastes. Unfortunately damaged kidneys find
it harder to do this, which is why your CKD cat may feel poorly.
AJ Fascetti & S Delaney from the University of California at Davis say in
Nutritional management of chronic renal disease
"Many of the clinical signs that you see in your animal such as vomiting,
lethargy, anorexia, diarrhea, oral ulcerations and the foul ammonia odor
to their breath can be partially or completely alleviated by reducing the
protein concentration in your animal's diet...Consumption of protein in amounts greater than what
your animal needs to maintain normal bodily functions can exacerbate these
clinical signs."
You will note the reference to not feeding more protein than your cat's
body needs to maintain normal function. This is the crux of the matter.
You do not want to feed an extremely low level of protein so your cat
suffers weight loss and malnutrition; but nor do you want to be loading
your cat's body with unnecessarily high levels of protein which contribute
to your cat feeling ill. The goal in CKD is not to feed low
protein or high protein. The goal is to feed sufficient protein with the
correct balance and number of amino acids to
maintain the cat's health and body weight, but in a form which needs as little
breaking down as possible. When talking about CKD, that is what we mean by "high quality protein",
not reaching for organic, high quality meat.
The protein goal for CKD cats used to be around 25% protein on a dry matter analysis
(DMA) basis. However, because of the potential problems with reduced
protein intake outlined above, the goal nowadays is usually a protein
level on a DMA basis of 28-35%. This is recommended by
Small Animal Clinical Nutrition — 6th Edition,
Chapter 37, Chronic Kidney Disease
(2019) Davenport D & Kirpensteijn J (Eds.) Mark Morris Institute, which states that "The
recommended range for DM protein levels in foods intended for most
patients with CKD is 28 to 35% for cats. Foods with less protein may be
needed to control signs of uremia in patients with more advanced CKD; in
these patients, it’s important to monitor for signs of protein deficiency.
In addition to the amount of protein, patients with CKD should receive
protein of high biologic value."
For most people, the
easiest way to achieve this is to feed a therapeutic kidney diet because these
diets have a protein level in this range. This does not mean they are low protein
foods.
Feeding cats with different nutritional needs: a
dilemma in the multicat household (2012) Dr M Scherk
Presentation to the 73rd SCIVAC International Congress 2012 says "A
note about restricted and high protein diets: these diets do not have too
little or too much protein, their protein levels fall within the
nutritional guidelines, merely at the low or at the high end of the
range.'
Evidence-based medicine: protein requirements in
dogs and cats with chronic kidney disease
(2017) Ross S Presentation to the 2017 Hill's Global Symposium
says "In one commercially available feline renal diet, the protein
content exceeds the AAFCO recommendations for crude protein content by 4%
dry matter (DM). Additionally, the composition of the protein supplies at
least 150% of the daily recommended amounts of 11 essential amino acids."
ISFM consensus guidelines on the diagnosis and
management of feline chronic kidney disease (2016)
Sparkes AH, Caney S, Chalhoub S, Elliott J, Finch N, Gajanayake I,
Langston C, Lefebvre H, White J & Quimby J Journal of Feline Medicine &
Surgery 18 pp219-239 state "Feline renal diets typically
contain 6–7 g of protein per 100 kcal (above the 5 g/100 kcal recommended
allowance for adult cats, but below the 9–10 g/100 kcal commonly seen in
maintenance diets). Energy requirements of older (>13 years) cats may
increase and severe protein restriction may lead to loss of lean tissue;
thus moderate protein restriction is recommended in CKD, together with
monitoring of lean body mass, weight and caloric intake." In other
words, the protein levels seen in therapeutic kidney diets should be
adequate for CKD cats, but you should monitor your cat's weight, muscle
levels and calorie intake.
If you find your cat starts to exhibit weight or muscle loss, you could
consider trying one of the therapeutic kidney diets with protein at the
higher end of the suggested range.
Feeding cats with different nutritional needs: a
dilemma in the multicat household (2012) Scherk M
Presentation to the 73rd SCIVAC International Congress 2012 says "The
protein restricted therapeutic diets are not all the same; there are some
marked differences in their composition, not just in protein sources and
quantities, but also in the calorie source, in their phosphorus,
potassium, and sodium content." As mentioned above,
Cats with IRIS stage 1 and 2 chronic kidney disease
maintain body weight and lean muscle mass when fed food having increased
caloric density, and enhanced concentrations of carnitine and essential
amino acids (2019) Hall JA,
Fritsch DA, Jewell DE, Burris PA & Gross KL Veterinary Record
184(6) pp190 compared two dry therapeutic kidney diets (Hill's
Prescription Diet k/d with chicken and Royal Canin Renal Support A) fed to
cats in IRIS stage 1 or 2. The Hill's food has around 34% protein on a DMA
basis whilst the Royal Canin A has around 24%. Cats fed the Hill's food
ate more calories, maintained or increased body weight and their kidney
bloodwork remained stable, whereas the cats fed the Royal Canin food lost
weight and their creatinine levels rose more quickly. (Most of the
researchers undertaking this study work for Hill's.
Personally I would try to
feed a food with a protein level of 35% on a dry matter analysis basis, or
as close to this as you can get.
If you are concerned about weight and/or muscle loss,
you can also consider adding foods with high biologic value but minimal nitrogenous
waste to your cat's therapeutic kidney diet. A good choice would be
egg whites.
If you cannot persuade your cat to eat a therapeutic kidney diet (see
Which Foods to Feed for tips on how to do this), you can also check
the
food data tables to find other foods which are relatively low
in protein; but don't forget the therapeutic kidney diets have other
important attributes, and the protein they do contain is good quality from
the CKD perspective, something which is not always easy to replicate with
non-therapeutic kidney foods.
When To Feed Reduced Protein
IRIS Stages 1
and 2
Because of the potential downsides of protein
restriction, it is not necessarily a good idea to feed reduced protein
food in all cases.
Treatment recommendations for CKD in cats
(2019) International Renal Interest Society
divides CKD into stages (see
How Bad is
It?) and suggests starting a therapeutic kidney diet in Stage 2, i.e. when the
cat's creatinine is over 1.6 mg/dl or 140 µmol/L. However for cats with
proteinuria, it
states "feed a renal clinical diet" regardless of the stage the cat is in.
Positive impact of nutritional interventions on
serum symmetric dimethylarginine and creatinine concentrations in
client-owned geriatric cats (2016) Hall JA, MacLeay J,
Yerramilli M, Obare E , Yerramilli M, Schiefelbein H, Paetau-Robinson I &
Jewell DE PLoS One 11(4) looked at feeding a therapeutic
kidney diet to cats in IRIS stage 1. The study concludes "Our results
suggest that cats with early renal insufficiency fed a test food designed
to promote healthy aging, over a 6 month period, were more likely to have
stable renal function evidenced by stable serum SDMA concentrations
compared with cats fed owner's-choice foods. Cats fed owner’s-choice foods
were more likely to have progressive renal insufficiency characterized by
increasing serum SDMA concentrations." However, the food fed in this trial
was specially formulated and is not commercially available. It is also
difficult to compare the effect of the therapeutic kidney diet because not
enough is known about the alternative foods that were fed.
Other vets believe that it is better to wait until the disease is more
advanced before starting a therapeutic kidney diet.
Managing chronic diseases cats (2005)
Veterinary Medicine Little S states "Don't restrict dietary protein
for cats experiencing mild to moderate chronic renal insufficiency
(creatinine 1.6 to 2.8 mg/dl, 140 to 250 μmol/l) because it can lead to
protein malnutrition. These cats require adequate protein and calories to
maintain body weight and to avoid muscle wasting and anemia."
If your cat also has hyperthyroidism, it can be even more of a concern
since hyperthyroid cats are prone to weight loss and muscle wasting.
Diet and nutritional management for hyperthyroid
cats (2011) Peterson ME (the man who discovered
hyperthyroidism in cats) states that "The major problem that I have with some of the
prescription kidney diets is that they restrict protein to the point that
some cats — especially those with concurrent hyperthyroidism — will
continue to catabolize their own muscle mass despite adequate control of
the thyroid condition." For cats with both CKD and hyperthyroidism,
he states that reducing protein should be avoided in IRIS stages 1 and 2,
but that phosphorus control is very important.
Unfortunately, it can often be easier to switch a cat
to a reduced protein diet when the cat is stable with lower numbers.
Treatment recommendations for CKD in cats
(2019)
International Renal Interest Society
says that introducing a therapeutic diet "may be accomplished more easily
early in the course of CKD, before inappetence develops." So if your early
stage cat is prepared to eat a therapeutic kidney diet, it is
worth trying one, even if initially you don't feed it exclusively. The manufacturers claim that their diets have adequate
protein levels for cats at every stage of CKD, but be sure to monitor your
cat's weight and body condition, and keep an eye on your cat's
albumin levels —
Prolonging life and kidney function
(2009) Chew DJ & DiBartola SP CVC in
Kansas City Proceedings states
"Maintenance of stable body weight and serum albumin concentration
suggests adequate intake of calories and protein whereas progressive
declines in body weight and serum albumin concentration suggest
malnutrition or progression of disease and are indications to increase the
amount of protein fed." See
Which Foods to Feed for more information.
If you are concerned,
consider adding foods with high biologic value but minimal nitrogenous
waste to your cat's therapeutic kidney diet. A good choice would be
egg whites.
If you decide not to feed reduced protein to your CKD
cat, please do ensure
that your cat has a low phosphorus intake and an increased
essential fatty
acids intake.
IRIS Stages 3
and 4
As stated above,
Treatment recommendations for CKD in cats
(2019)
International Renal Interest Society
divides CKD into stages (see
How Bad is
It?) and suggests starting a therapeutic kidney diet in Stage 2, i.e.
when the cat's creatinine is over 1.6 mg/dl or 140 µmol/L. Cats who are in
Stages 3 and 4 would therefore also be advised to eat a therapeutic kidney
diet.
Another factor to consider is your cat's BUN level.
Since
BUN is influenced by protein intake,
it does often help the cat feel better if you restrict protein intake as
your cat's BUN levels rise. Dr D
Polzin states in
Chronic kidney disease (2007)
Delaware Valley Academy of Veterinary Medicine "Urea, once thought to be “the” uremic toxin, is not a major cause of
uremic toxicity, although it may
contribute to some of the clinical abnormalities, including anorexia,
malaise, and vomiting." Generally speaking, once BUN levels are over 60
mg/dl (urea over 21 µmol/L), you are more likely to see symptoms such as
vomiting and nausea, so if you are not
already feeding reduced protein, this may be the time to start.
In
Slowing the progression of chronic renal failure
(2004) Dr GF Grauer states that "As the renal failure progresses,
additional dietary protein reduction will likely be necessary. Dietary
protein reduction should be initiated when the animal’s blood urea
nitrogen concentration is between 60 and 80 mg/dl."
You may panic if you cannot get your cat to eat a reduced protein food.
Take a deep breath.
Managing chronic diseases cats (2005)
Veterinary Medicine Little S states "Never try to force an anorexic
patient with chronic renal insufficiency to eat a protein-restricted diet.
Instead, concentrate on encouraging anorexic patients to eat." Focus on
getting food into your cat and getting him or her stabilised before you
worry about feeding reduced protein. See the
Which Foods to Feed
page for more tips on getting your cat to eat the therapeutic kidney diet
and what to do if you can't succeed.
Treatment recommendations for CKD in cats
(2019)
International Renal Interest Society
states for Stage 4 cats "Intensify efforts to prevent protein / calorie
malnutrition. Consider feeding tube intervention (e.g., percutaneous
gastrostomy tube)." If you use such a tube, you can feed a therapeutic
kidney diet very easily.
See the
Persuading Your Cat
To Eat page for more information on feeding tubes and tips on
getting your cat to eat.
Whatever you do, monitor your cat's weight and muscle status closely.
Phosphorus
Controlling phosphorus levels is extremely important for CKD cats, because
high
phosphorus levels are very damaging to their health and can make the
disease progress more quickly.
This is such an important topic that I have an entire
page devoted to
phosphorus control. Please read it and do
everything you can to keep your cat's phosphorus levels low - it can make
all the difference to your cat's wellbeing and can also prolong survival.
Fat
Just as cats need a diet relatively high in protein, so
they also need relatively high levels of fat compared to a human or dog.
Geometric analysis of macronutrient selection in the
adult domestic cat, Felis catus
(2011) Hewson-Hughes AK, Hewson-Hughes VL, Miller AT, Hall SR, Simpson SJ
& Raubenheimer D Journal of Experimental Biology 214
pp1039-1051, a study in which cats were not allowed to choose how much
they ate, but were able to select the mix of nutrients that they
preferred, found that the fat target for healthy cats is about
9g a day or 36%.
Older cats may process fat less efficiently than younger cats, which may
be a factor in weight loss.
Skinny old cats: why some senior cats lose weight. What's going
on?
(2014) Williams D DVM360
Magazine
states "The incidence of low fat digestibility
increases with age, affecting 10% to 15% of mature cats (8 to 12 years
old) and 30% of geriatric cats (> 12 years old). In some geriatric cats,
fat digestibility was found to be as low as 30%, and the only clinical
signs were large stools (not frank diarrhea) and low body weight."
Fat does not result in a lot of waste products like protein, so processing
it is not a strain on the kidneys; plus cholesterol
is not an issue for cats the way it is for humans.
Your cat's nutritional needs
(2006) National Research Council states "The
maximum amount of fat in the cat’s diet can be reasonably high without any
known adverse effects. In many cat foods, 50% or more of the energy comes
from fat. Studies indicate that cat foods containing even higher amounts
of fat are safe."
Fat has been implicated in the development of obesity in healthy cats, but
obesity is hardly a problem for the average CKD cat; in fact, since fat
contains twice as many calories as protein or carbohydrate, a diet
relatively high in fat can help a CKD cat to maintain his/her weight
whilst placing less strain on the kidneys.
In most therapeutic kidney foods, the fat content is
increased to compensate for the lower protein levels. According to
Nutritional management of chronic kidney disease in
cats and dogs (2016) Cline MG
Today's Veterinary Practice 6(2),
the increased fat content also
helps maintain palatability.
Some senior cat foods also have relatively
high levels of fat and relatively low levels of protein; as a bonus, they
often also have low phosphorus levels. Therefore, if your cat won't eat a
therapeutic kidney diet, it is worth considering senior foods, although do
check the protein level is not too low.
Sodium
The kidneys cannot process sodium as effectively in
CKD, which increases the risk of hypertension (high blood pressure) in
humans. It used to be thought that the same applied to cats, and it was
therefore recommended that sodium intake should be restricted. However,
one study,
Effects of dietary sodium chloride intake
on renal function and blood pressure in cats with normal and reduced renal
function (2004) Buranakarl C, Mathur S & Brown
SA American Journal of Veterinary Research 65(5) pp620-7
found that "this common dietary maneuver could contribute to hypokalemic
nephropathy and progressive renal injury in cats."
Effects of sodium chloride on selected parameters in
cats (2006) Kirk CA, Jewell DE, Lowry SR Veterinary
Therapeutics: Research in Applied Veterinary Medicine 7(4)
pp333-346 found that sodium intake appeared to have no effect on in blood
pressure in CKD cats, but that levels of BUN, creatinine and phosphorus
were higher in the cats eating a high sodium diet compared to those eating
a low sodium diet.
Effects of dietary sodium chloride on health
parameters in mature cats (2009) Xu H, Laflamme DP & Long GL
Journal of Feline Medicine & Surgery 11(6) pp435-41 examined a
low sodium diet (0.55%) and a high sodium diet (1.11%) fed to mature cats
over a period of six months. Even in cats with creatinine over 1.6mg/dl,
"there remained no evidence of adverse effects associated with increased
salt intake. These results are consistent with the majority of other
studies evaluating sodium intake in cats, as well as with the National
Research Council's assessment, all of which indicate that sodium at 1.5%
of the diet dm is not harmful to healthy cats."
Effects of dietary salt intake on renal function: a
2-year study in healthy aged cats (2013) Reynolds BS, Chetboul
V, Nguyen P, Testault I, Concordet DV, Carlos Sampedrano C, Elliott J,
Trehiou-Sechi E, Abadie J, Biourge V & Lefebvre HP Journal of
Veterinary Internal Medicine 27(3) pp507-15 compared cats fed a
high sodium diet with cats fed the same diet but without the high sodium
levels. The study concludes "The results of this 2 year study do not
support the suggestion that chronic increases in dietary salt intake are
harmful to renal function in older cats."
Pet food safety: sodium in pet foods (2008)
Chandler ML Topics in Companion Animal Medicine 23(3)
pp148-53 states that "there is no strong evidence that increased dietary
sodium increases the risk of hypertension in dogs and cats, and the
current recommendation for hypertensive animals is to avoid high dietary
salt intake without making a specific effort to restrict it... Increased
dietary sodium increases urine output and may decrease the risk of forming
calcium oxalate uroliths due to the decrease in relative supersaturation
of solutes. However, caution should be used in increasing the sodium
intake of patients with renal disease as increased dietary sodium may have
a negative effect on the kidneys independent of any effect on blood
pressure."
Sodium in feline nutrition
(2017) Nguyen P, Reynolds B, Zentek J, Paßlack N & Leray V
Journal of Animal Physiology and Animal Nutrition 101 pp403-420
looked at the role of sodium in cats and states "there is no evidence of
any deleterious effect of dietary sodium levels as high as 740 mg/MJ
metabolizable energy, which can therefore be considered the SUL [safe
upper limit] based on current knowledge."
So should you restrict sodium intake or not?
Treatment recommendations for CKD in cats
(2019) International Renal Interest Society
state on page 5 that there is no evidence that reducing sodium intake is
helpful for CKD cats, and that it should certainly not take the place of
medication for
hypertension,
but if you do opt to reduce your cat's sodium intake, you should do it gradually. The
food data tables
provide information about the sodium content of many cat foods available
in the USA and UK.
Potassium
Around 30% of CKD cats have
potassium
levels which are too low. This occurs because potassium is easily lost
through increased urination and vomiting. Therapeutic kidney diets contain
extra potassium (all cat foods need some potassium), and this is usually
in the form of potassium citrate, because potassium citrate may help with
a problem seen in some CKD cats called
metabolic acidosis.
If your cat refuses to eat a therapeutic diet, your
vet can give you a potassium supplement instead, if appropriate. Some cats
need a potassium supplement regardless of whether they eat the therapeutic kidney
diet.
Many commercial cat foods are acidified in order to
reduce the risk of FLUTD
(feline lower urinary tract disease. These foods often say that they are
designed to maintain urinary tract health; or they may contain
cranberries or additional
vitamin C. However, these foods (which are
actually designed to treat a different kind of problem to CKD) may have
the effect of increasing the amounts of potassium lost in the urine, which
is bad for CKD cats. It is therefore best not to feed acidified foods to
CKD cats, who tend to have quite high acid levels anyway.
Please see the
Potassium
page for more information about potassium.
Carbohydrates
Cats only have a limited need for carbohydrates. A cat
catching his/her own food would only eat the small amount of carbohydrate
contained in a mouse's stomach. In a study in which cats were not allowed
to choose how much they ate, but were able to select the mix of nutrients
that they preferred,
Geometric analysis of macronutrient selection in the
adult domestic cat, Felis catus
(2011) Hewson-Hughes AK, Hewson-Hughes VL, Miller AT, Hall SR, Simpson SJ
& Raubenheimer D Journal of Experimental Biology 214
pp1039-1051, it was found that target intake for carbohydrate in cats was only 8g
a day or 12% of total food intake. The study also states "Our analysis indicates
that cats have a ceiling for carbohydrate intake, which limits ingestion
and constrains them to deficits in protein and fat intake (relative to
their target) on high-carbohydrate foods."
In
The carnivore connection to nutrition in cats
(2002) Zoran D Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association
221 pp1559-67, Dr Zoran writes "It is clear that cats have a
greater need than dogs or other omnivores for protein in their diet. Cats
also have several physiologic adaptations that reflect their expected low
CHO [carbohydrate] intake... These specific differences do not mean cats
cannot use starch. In fact, cats are extremely efficient in their use of
simple sugars. However, it does underscore their development as carnivores
and the expected low amounts of grain in their typical diet. These
digestive differences may mean that high amounts of CHO in diets may have
untoward effects on cats."
Therefore, if you are trying to reduce your CKD cat's
protein intake, I would recommend increasing the fat in the diet (see
above)
rather than the carbohydrates. If you are feeding a therapeutic kidney diet,
this will often be done automatically — many of these diets increase the
fat content (rather than the carbohydrates) in order to offset the reduced
protein content.
PetCoach has an interesting article
about carbohydrates in the feline diet.
Fibre
Fibre is the non-digestible component of complex
carbohydrate. It is important for good digestive health. Increased fibre
may help with elevated calcium levels in the body (hypercalcaemia),
although one type of fibre, fructooligosaccharides or FOS, may actually
increase calcium levels in the body (see
below).
It may also
assist with two commonly seen CKD problems,
toxin reduction and the control of
constipation.
Fibre Types: Fermentable
versus Non-Fermentable
There are a number of ways of categorising fibre types, but one way is to
divide it into fermentable and
non-fermentable.
Which fibres are fermentable depends upon the species
of bacteria eating the fibre in the cat's gastrointestinal tract.
Diet and large intestinal disease in dogs and cats
(1998) JW Simpson The Journal of Nutrition 128 2717S-2722S
has a table showing soluble and fermentable fibres.
In terms of general health, you do not necessarily want
the most fermentable fibres.
Dietary fiber for cats: in vitro fermentation of selected fiber sources by
cat fecal inoculum and in vivo utilization of diets containing selected
fiber sources and their blends (1995) Sunvold GD, Fahey GC Jr,
Merchen NR, Bourquin LD, Titgemeyer EC, Bauer LL & Reinhart GA Journal
of Animal Science 73(8) pp2329-39 examined the fermentability
of various fibres. It concludes that the diet "which contained the most
fermentable fibers, severely decreased nutrient digestibility and resulted
in poor stool characteristics. Diets that contain moderately fermentable
fiber provide fermentation end products that may be important in
maintaining the health of the gastrointestinal tract of the cat."
Fermentable Fibre for Toxin Reduction
There has long been interest in whether other bodily
mechanisms might be useful for relieving the load on damaged CKD kidneys.
Bowel as a substitute in renal failure
(1996) Friedman EA American Journal of Kidney Diseases 28(6)
pp943-50 states "Extraction, modification, or recycling of nitrogenous
wastes by the gastrointestinal tract is a potentially low-cost means of
substituting for missing renal function. Multiple approaches to the bowel
as a substitute kidney have been attempted."
One way of doing this may be via increased fibre
intake in the form of fermentable fibre (prebiotics). Fermentable fibre provides a
source of carbohydrate for the bacteria in the gut. These bacteria, which
are essential to health, increase in number when provided with additional
fermentable fibre, and the more bacteria there are, the more nitrogen is
excreted in the faeces. This increased faecal excretion
may help to reduce the load on the kidneys by diverting the excretion of
urea from the kidneys.
You can read more about this in the
Treatments chapter.
Non-Fermentable Fibre for Constipation
Non-fermentable fibre can be helpful for CKD cats
because it reduces the risk of constipation, a common problem in CKD cats,
by holding water in the stool. Most commercial cat foods have sufficient
levels of fibre for a healthy cat, but if your cat suffers from
constipation you may wish to add more fibre in the form of something such
as pumpkin, baby peas or psyllium.
Please see
Constipation
for more information on dealing with constipation.
Feline Constipation explains more about
fibre and gut health.
Fibre: Side
Effects and Interactions
Some forms of fibre, such as fructooligosaccharides
(FOS), may also bind calcium in the small intestine and lead to an
increase in calcium levels in the body (hypercalcaemia).
This can be a problem for cats who already have high blood calcium levels. Inulin and guar gum
may do this, as may
slippery elm bark and
lactulose, two treatments
commonly used for constipation in CKD cats.
The effects of gum arabic oral treatment on the
metabolic profile of chronic renal failure patients under regular
haemodialysis in Central Sudan (2008) Ali AA, Ali KE, Fadlalla AE
& Khalid KE Natural Product Research 22(1) p12-21 found that
patients given gum arabic for three months had lower BUN, creatinine and
phosphorus levels, but calcium levels increased significantly.
Too much fibre may also prevent your cat from absorbing
sufficient nutrients or calories from his/her food. Fibre may also affect
taurine levels in some foods.
I would therefore recommend discussing additional fibre with your vet
before adding it, and avoiding its use in a cat who already has high
calcium levels.
Essential Fatty Acids
(EFAs)
What are Essential Fatty Acids
Essential fatty acids (EFAs) are polyunsaturated fats (sometimes
abbreviated as PUFA). They are essential because the cat's body cannot
synthesise them in sufficient amounts, so they have to be obtained from
food.
Essential Fatty Acids Types
The two main types of EFAs are omega-3 and omega-6.
Commercial diets tend to contain far more omega-6, partly because omega-6
EFAs are cheaper and more stable, but this may create a potentially
harmful imbalance. The correct balance is not yet known, though some
believe it is probably around 5:1 (omega-6:omega-3).
Within the omega-3 category, two common acids are eicosapentaenoic acid
(EPA) and docosahexaenoic acid (DHA). Arachidonic acid (AA) is an omega-6
type.
PetCoach has a very helpful overview
of the different types of essential fatty acids.
Qualitative risk assessment of chronic renal failure
development in healthy female cats based on the content of
eicosapentaenoic acid in adipose tissue and that of arachidonic acid in
plasma cholesteryl esters (2005) Plantinga EA, Hovenier
R & Beynen AC Veterinary Research Communications 29(4) pp281-6
concluded that "the fatty acid composition of cat foods should be
determined and that, if deemed necessary, the ingredient composition
should be altered so that the content of EPA is raised and that of AA
is lowered."
Essential Fatty Acids Benefits
Essential fatty acids are important for many
bodily functions. It has been known for many years that they have an
effect on the skin - the first signs of an imbalance or deficiency are
usually a dry coat, itchy skin or matted fur. Recently it appears that
they may have an important role in controlling inflammation. In one study,
Effect of nutritional interventions on longevity in
senior cats (2007) Cupp CJ, Jean-Philippe C, Kerr WW, Patil AR &
Perez-Camargo G The International Journal of Applied Research in
Veterinary Medicine 5(3), healthy older cats fed a diet
containing antioxidants including additional essential fatty acids lived
significantly longer.
Dietary omega-3 fatty acid
supplementation increases the rate of muscle protein synthesis in older
adults: a randomized controlled trial
(2011) Smith GI, Atherton P, Reeds DN, Mohammed BS, Rankin D, Rennie MJ,
Mittendorfer B American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 93(2)
pp402-12 investigated the effects of EFAs on loss of muscle mass in
healthy older human adults (sarcopaenia). It concluded "Omega-3 fatty
acids stimulate muscle protein synthesis in older adults and may be useful
for the prevention and treatment of sarcopenia."
A product called 1-TDC which contains essential fatty acids appears to
improve periodontal disease in cats. See
Dental Problems
for more information.
Essential Fatty Acids for CKD Cats
Research in rats and humans indicates that the
addition of omega-3 fatty acids to the diet may delay the progression of
CKD.
Oxidative stress and chronic
kidney disease (2008) Brown SA The
Veterinary Clinics of North America. Small Animal Practice 38(1)
pp157-66 added essential fatty acid supplements in the form of fish oil to
dog foods. It concludes "newer data indicate that dietary supplementation
with specific antioxidants is an important consideration for limiting
renal oxidant stress and progression of CKD."
EFAs may also be of benefit to CKD cats.
Nutritional management of renal disease: an
evidence-based approach (2014)
Sanderson SL Today's Veterinary Practice 4(1) pp51-56 states
"When nephrons are destroyed in CKD, the remaining viable
nephrons hypertrophy in an attempt to compensate, resulting in a
maladaptive increase in glomerular capillary pressure (GCP). Dietary
omega-3 fatty acid supplementation in the form of fish oil can have
beneficial effects in reducing GCP."
However,
Nutritional management of renal disease
(2008) Sturgess K Presentation to the World Small Animal Veterinary Association
World Congress states that "it is possible that
supplementation of diets with PUFA may increase renal damage associated
with lipid peroxidation (degradation of carbon=carbon double bond by
oxidants). The benefits over risks of increasing PUFA levels in the diets
of cats with CRD have not been established." It goes on to say that the
ratio of omega 3 to omega 6 may be crucial. This ties in with what
one kidney specialist vet has informed me, that
oversupplementation can throw off the correct ratio of omega-3s to
omega-6s, and might be detrimental in some cases.
Potential adverse effects of Omega-3 fatty acids in
dogs and cats (2013) Lenox CE & Bauer
JE Journal of Veterinary Internal Medicine 27(2) states "Important potential adverse effects of omega-3
fatty acid supplementation include altered platelet function,
gastrointestinal adverse effects, detrimental effects on wound
healing, lipid peroxidation, potential for nutrient excess and toxin
exposure, weight gain, altered immune function, effects
on glycemic control and insulin sensitivity, and nutrient-drug
interactions."
Omega-3 fatty acid supplementation for dogs and cats
with heart disease (2014) Nutrition Service at
Cummings Veterinary Medical Center at Tufts University states "Potential
risk factors include decreased platelet function and coagulation, and
possibly suppressed wound healing...Other potential effects include soft
feces, diarrhea, flatulence, vomiting, and halitosis."
Nutrition and renal function: effects of dietary
lipids on renal function (1999) Polzin
DJ, Osborne CA, James K, Purina Research Report, adapted from
articles presented at the 1998 Purina Nutrition Forum, sees things
differently. It states: "In cats, dietary supplementation with n-3 PUFA
had no apparent deleterious effect on lipid metabolism, immune function,
blood pressure, or renal function. At higher levels of supplementation,
renal function was actually increased in normal cats. These data support
the assertion that this dietary maneuver is safe for normal cats and
provides some encouragement for further consideration for dietary n-3 PUFA
supplementation in cats with renal disease, systemic hypertension, or
hypersensitivity reactions."
The study which has led many vets to look positively at
the use of essential fatty acids in cats,
Retrospective study of the survival of
cats with acquired chronic renal insufficiency offered different
commercial diets
(2005) Plantinga EA, Everts H, Kastelein AM & Beynen AC
Veterinary Record 157(7) pp185-187, found that cats who ate
therapeutic kidney diets with the highest amount of EPA survived for 23
months versus an average of 12 months for cats who ate diets containing
lower EPA levels.
Therapeutic kidney foods have an increased level of essential fatty acids compared to standard cat foods,
so if you are feeding such a food, supplementation may not be necessary. If you wish to give
additional essential fatty acids, ask your vet if they are appropriate for your cat.
Almost everybody I know of who has added essential fatty acids to their
cat's treatment plan, whether in a therapeutic kidney diet or as a
supplement, has been happy with the results, reporting an improvement in
general wellbeing. Additional EFAs do cause vomiting in some cats though,
and I've heard from a number of people whose cats had pancreatitis and who felt essential fatty acids did not agree
with these cats, causing problems such as diarrhoea.
Potential adverse effects of Omega-3 fatty acids in
dogs and cats (2013) Lenox CE & Bauer
JE Journal of Veterinary Internal Medicine 27(2) states "Pancreatitis also is a concern when feeding high fat diets or high doses
of fatty acid supplementation, especially in dogs with a known risk of
pancreatitis. However, there are no reports of omega-3 fatty acid or
fish oil supplements causing pancreatitis in dogs, cats, or humans.
Theoretically, omega-3 fatty acids could prevent pancreatitis because of
decreased blood triglyceride concentrations. An extremely high dosage of
omega-3 fatty acids or a fish oil supplement in addition to a very high
fat diet would likely be required to induce pancreatitis." It goes on to
say "Clinical patients that develop diarrhea or other adverse
gastrointestinal effects may need a decreased dosage of omega-3 fatty
acids as well as other dietary modification."
Essential Fatty Acids: Supplement Types
Fish Oil
Since cats as obligate carnivores benefit from
animal-based products, the most appropriate form of essential fatty acid
supplement is fish oil. Fish oil contains omega-3 fatty acids in the form
of eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA) and docosahexaenoic acid (DHA).
Oils from the liver, such as cod liver oil, are not suitable because they
contain too much vitamin A and D.
Omega-3 fatty acid supplementation for dogs and cats
with heart disease (2014) Nutrition Service at Cummings
Veterinary Medical Center at Tufts University states "We also recommend
avoiding cod liver oil for this purpose as it is too high in vitamins A
and D when administered at this dose and can cause toxicity of these
vitamins."
Look for an oil pressed from the flesh only and containing EPA and DHA.
If fish oils are given, extra vitamin E is also
required in order to avoid a problem called
steatitis.
Vitamin E requirement of adult cats increases slightly
with high dietary intake of polyunsaturated fatty acids (2002)
Hendriks WH, Wu YB, Shields RG, Newcomb M, Rutherfurd KJ, Belay T & Wilson
J The Journal of Nutrition: Supplement: Waltham International Symposium
132 pp1613S-1615S discusses this. Many products, especially
veterinary ones, already contain vitamin E in an appropriate dosage (it
may be referred to as tocopherol), in which case you do not need to
supplement Vitamin E.
If for some reason the product you buy does not contain vitamin E,
AAFCO PFC Committee Report/Minutes
(2015) states on page 16 "Add 10 IU Vitamin E above the minimum
concentration for each gram of fish oil per kilogram of diet." (The link
also gives the minimum concentration). However, I would ask your vet how
much to give, because too much vitamin E can be dangerous.
Astro's
Oil Advanced Renal Care Formula
Astro's Oil Advanced Renal Care Formula,
previously called Astro's CRF Oil,
is a fish oil-based
supplement which was created by a human
doctor to treat his own CKD cat. It has been on the market since January
2007. The manufacturer states that the product was tested on an informal
basis on 18 CKD cats in the Montreal area over a period of about eight
months.
This product is basically a combination of essential fatty acids,
vitamin E (which you need to
add when you are supplementing fish oils, but which is also an antioxidant) and
CoQ10 (ubiquinol), also an antioxidant, but
in a concentrated formula. There is more information about it in the
Treatments section.
Krill Oil
Some people prefer to give krill oil to their cats
because they find their cats tolerate it better. Krill oil is made from
crustaceans rather than fish and contains additional antioxidants called
astaxanthin and canthaxanthin. Studies have indicated that these
antioxidants may inhibit cancer and bacterial infection in mice but
Astaxanthin uptake in domestic dogs and cats
(2010) Park JS, Kim HW, Mathison BD, Hayek MG, Massimino
S, Reinhart GA & Chew BP Nutrition & Metabolism 7:52 pp1-8
states that "domestic dogs and cats fed astaxanthin generally showed
different biokinetic profiles when compared to humans and other species.
Whether astaxanthin supplementation can modulate immune and
anti-inflammatory/antioxidative function remains to be elucidated."
The essential fatty acids in krill oil are phospholipids (in fish-based
oils they are triglycerides). I do not know for sure if this has any
implications for phosphorus levels in CKD cats but a later study in rats,
Feeding different omega-3 polyunsaturated fatty acid
sources influences renal fatty acid composition, inflammation, and
occurrence of nephrocalcinosis in female sprague-dawley rats
(2013) Gigliotti JC, Benedito VA, Livengood R, Oldaker C, Nanda N &
Tou, JC Food and Nutrition Sciences 4 pp125-136 concludes
"In contrast, rats consuming KO [krill oil] and to a lesser extent FO
[flax oil] showed evidence of renal calcification and tubulo-interstitial
injury. This was due to increased urinary P excretion associated with the
phospholipids content of these oils sources. Although further studies are
needed, susceptible individuals should be aware of a potential risk of
increasing phospholipids consumption on renal health."
Personally, I think I would be more comfortable using fish oil.
If you are in Europe, especially Italy, you may be offered a new product
called Nefrokrill, which contains
potassium
citrate,
lanthanum carbonate (a phosphorus binder) and essential fatty acids.
You can read more about it
here.
Vegetable-based
Oils
Vegetable-based oils, such as coconut oil or olive oil or
flax seed (linseed) oil, are not
recommended, because they do not contain the essential fatty acids which a
cat needs.
Dietary fish oil and flaxseed oil
suppress inflammation and immunity in cats
(2011) Park HJ, Park JS, Hayek MG, Reinhart GA, Chew BP Veterinary
Immunology & Immunopathology 141(3-4) pp301-6 found that "fish
and flaxseed oil can reduce skin inflammatory responses in cats, however,
flaxseed oil appears less immunosuppressive than fish oil."
Others go further.
Omega-3 fatty acid supplementation for dogs and cats
with heart disease (2014) Nutrition Service at
Cummings Veterinary Medical Center at Tufts University states
"Flaxseed/flaxseed oil also are high in omega-3 fatty acids but are
ineffective for providing omega-3 fatty acids to dogs and cats so should
be avoided."
Essential Fatty Acids Dosage
It can be a bit tricky working out an appropriate dose
of essential fatty acids for cats. The National Research Council gives an
upper limit for dogs but gives no upper limit for cats.
Fish Oils Dosage
Pet MD discusses the dangers of giving
too much but says with reference to the NRA recommendations for dogs,
"Translating the data suggests that a dose between 20-55mg combined EPA
and DHA per pound of body weight is safe for dogs and cats. This dose is
far less than those used to treat serious conditions where the risk of
side effects is less important."
Top 5 therapeutic uses of omega-3 fatty acids
(2015) Chandler ML Clinician's Brief Feb 2015 pp78-80
states "the amount to supplement is somewhat empiric and depends on the
amount in the diet. Common recommendations are 40 mg/kg EPA plus 25 mg/kg
DHA, but the amount in studies also varies."
Potential adverse effects of Omega-3 fatty acids in
dogs and cats (2013) Lenox CE & Bauer
JE Journal of Veterinary Internal Medicine 27(2) states
"Target ranges for EPA and DHA vary quite widely for different conditions,
but typically fall between 50 and 220 mg/kg body weight. The higher
dosages often are used to lower serum triglyceride concentrations in
patients with hypertriglyceridemia, whereas lower dosages are more commonly
used for inflammatory conditions, renal disease, and cardiac disease."
As far as cats with heart disease are concerned,
Omega-3 fatty acid supplementation for dogs and cats
with heart disease (2014) Nutrition Service at
Cummings Veterinary Medical Center at Tufts University states "The
dose of omega-3 fatty acids we currently recommend for dogs and cats with
heart failure is 40 mg/kg eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA) + 25 mg/kg
docosahexaenoic acid (DHA) per day. There are a small number of commercial
pet foods that contain this dose (for example, the Royal Canin Early
Cardiac Diet for Dogs). However, in most cases, supplements are needed to
achieve this dose."
As you can see, there is no definitive dose, and many of the
recommendations relate to a particular amount of
EPA (eicosapentaenoic
acid).
-
One commonly used dose on Tanya's Feline CKD Support Group is 22mg
of EPA per
kg of cat per day (10mg per lb of cat per day). So if your cat weighs 8 lb
(3.6kg), you would give a product containing 80mg of EPA each day.
-
Another recommended dosage is 180 EPA and 120 DHA per 10 lbs (4.5kg) of
cat; this is more than double the earlier dose.
You will need to check the product you are considering to see how
much EPA it contains. Many fish oil capsules are 1000mg strength. However,
only around 20% of it tends to be EPA (with around 10% DHA), so a 1000mg
capsule will contain around 200mg of EPA and 100mg of DHA.
I expect your head is spinning by now! Generally speaking, it is probably safe to give your
cat one 1000mg fish oil capsule daily. Do check with your vet first
though. Therapeutic kidney diets contain increased amounts of EFAs, so if
your cat is eating such a food, you may not need supplementation, or may need a reduced dose.
Krill Oil Dosage
The dosage for krill oil (which is made from crustaceans rather than fish)
is 500mg per day.
If you are using Nefrokrill, the dosage is
here.
Essential Fatty Acids: How to Give
Essential fatty acids are commonly available in either
capsule form or in pump bottles. Do not give the oil directly into your
cat's mouth, or s/he may aspirate the oil. Instead, mix the oil (you can
open the capsule) with your cat's food. You don't have to give the daily
dose in one amount, you can divide it between your cat's meals.
Although most cats like fish, the oils can be a bit
strong, and many cats dislike the smell. Some cats may vomit after eating
them. It is therefore wise to start off very slowly, just using one drop
at first which you add to a smelly food that may disguise the taste, and
gradually increase the dose over several days or even weeks. If your cat
still hates it, you can either decant the oil into a gelcap, try finding a less
smelly product, or discuss with your vet whether to continue with the
supplement. Some members of my support group find krill oil is more
acceptable to their cats.
It takes 2-3 months to see the full effect of essential
fatty acid supplements. If you think they help your cat, you should use
them on an ongoing basis. If you don't see any difference, or if your cat
seems to react badly to them e.g. increased vomiting, speak to your vet
about stopping them.
Essential fatty acids can easily go off (they become rancid).
Store them in the fridge, and be sure to sniff them before giving them to
your cat.
Essential Fatty Acids: Where to Buy
Veterinary products are helpful for working out
cat-sized dosages but often contain Omega-6 and/or Omega-9 fatty acids,
which you don't need, so ensure your selected product only contains Omega-3 oils.
Many people simply use human products, and in some
cases they and their cat use the same one. Look for pharmaceutical grade
products (these are usually steam distilled) that are odourless if possible. If your cat doesn't like the
brand you buy, you may need to shop around to find one that is acceptable.
If for some reason the product you buy does not contain vitamin E,
AAFCO PFC Committee Report/Minutes
(2015) states on page 16 "Add 10 IU Vitamin E above the minimum
concentration for each gram of fish oil per kilogram of diet." (The link
also gives the minimum concentration). However, I would ask your vet how
much to give, because too much vitamin E can be dangerous.
USA
Brands Overview
PetCoach has a very helpful overview
of essential fatty acids, with a comparison of various brands available in
the USA.
Omega-3 fatty acid supplementation for dogs and cats
with heart disease (2014) Nutrition Service at Cummings
Veterinary Medical Center at Tufts University recommends particular brands
for cats and dogs with heart disease.
Consumer Lab has a summary of its findings
with regard to the quality of EFAs, including the names of some of the US
products which met with its approval, but you need to be a member to read
it.
Fish Oils
Welactin is a veterinary product available
in both softgel capsules and pump bottle. The ESA quantities have changed
recently. One capsule contains 125mg EPA
and 85mg DHA. One pump contains approximately 1.25 ml and provides 160mg
of EPA and 105g of DHA.
Nordic Naturals Omega-3 Pet
is based on anchovies and sardines and is a
popular choice on Tanya's CKD Support Group. It costs US$15.95 direct from
the manufacturer. It is also available from
Pure Formulas
for US$11.53 with free shipping. You can often find it on Amazon but a
couple of members of my support group have found it does not seem to last
too well when purchasing it there.
Iceland Pure Unscented Sardine-Anchovy for Pets
is also popular. It is available from
Chewy
for US$24.04.
Bonnie and Clyde Wild Omega-3 is a
Canadian brand used by a number of Tanya Support Group members. It is also
available from
Healthy Pets for US$32.99.
Sundown Naturals Fish Oil
is available from CVS. It is 1000mg with total EPA and DHA of 300mg.
Grizzly Salmon Oil is made from wild
Alaskan salmon.
Krill Oil
Now Neptune
is
available from Amazon for US$30.14 for 120 capsules. If you are in Canada,
60 softgels are available from
Healthy Planet Canada for CAN$37.99.
Canada
Nordic Naturals Omega-3 Pet is available
from
iHerb for CAN$18.86. iHerb will ship
to many other countries.
Bonnie and Clyde Wild Omega-3 is
a Canadian brand used by a number of Tanya Support Group members. It is
widely available in Canada.
Now Neptune krill oil
60 softgels are available from
Healthy Planet Canada for CAN$37.99.
UK
Nordic Naturals Omega-3 Pet
is a popular choice on Tanya's CKD Support Group.
It is available from
Amazon UK for
£24.99. A couple of members of my support group have found it does not seem
to last too well when purchasing from Amazon in the USA but I have not had
any complaints about buying it from Amazon UK.
Your vet may also have a suitable product in stock.
Amino Acids
Amino acids are the components of protein. There are 23
amino acids which cats need, and they can manufacture twelve of these
themselves, but the other eleven must be obtained from food. The ones
which the cat cannot manufacture are called essential amino acids.
Taurine is one example of an amino acid which
cats must obtain from food.
PetCoach has some information
about
essential amino acids for cats.
The protein paradigm: assessing dietary protein in
health and disease (2015)
Shmalberg J Today's Veterinary Practice 5(6) has some good
information about amino acids.
If you feed a commercial diet, it will contain the
correct balance of amino acids for cats. However, if you feed homemade
food, it is critical to ensure that the diet has the correct balance of
amino acids.
Some highlights in elucidating the peculiar
nutritional needs of cats (2007) Morris JG & Rogers QR Nestle
Purina 2007 Nutrition Forum Proceedings found that problems related to
amino acid deficiencies occurred after a couple of weeks, but that
problems relating to a lack of arginine occurred within less than a day
(arginine deficiency can be fatal in cats very quickly).
Plasma amino acid profiles in cats with naturally
acquired chronic renal failure (1999) Goldstein RE, Marks SL,
Cowgill LD, Kass PH & Rogers QR American Journal of Veterinary Research
60(1) pp109-13, found that CKD cats in all stages of the disease had
lower levels of amino acids than healthy cats. However, they concluded
"the magnitude of these changes is mild and of little clinical relevance."
This is an older study, and it might eventually be shown that
supplementary amino acids are in fact helpful to CKD cats.
Inflammation contributes to low plasma
amino acid concentrations in patients with chronic kidney disease
(2005) Suliman ME, Rashid Qureshi A, Stenvinkel P, Pecoits-Filho R, Bárány
P, Heimbürger O, Anderstam B, Rodriguez Ayala E, Divino Filho JC,
Alvestrand A & Lindholm B American Journal of Clinical Nutrition
82(2) pp342-349 also found that amino acid levels are low in human CKD
patients with inflammation and states that the inflammation may be the
cause.
Oral supplement of six selective amino acids arrests
progression of renal failure in uremic patients (2004) Yatzidis H
International Urology and Nephrology 36(4) pp91-8 found that
amino acid supplements appeared to help human patients with
glomerulonephritis.
There are a couple of amino acid supplements that are marketed for CKD
cats. There is more information about them on the
Holistic Treatments page.
Taurine
The amino acid of greatest relevance to cats is
taurine. Taurine is most concentrated in the heart, retinas (eyes) and the
brain. In the cat, it is essential for the digestion of fats, which cannot
be achieved without taurine in the diet.
Taurine and inflammation: a new approach to an old
problem (1997) Letter in the Journal of Leukocyte
Biology 61(2) pp231-2 concludes "we believe that taurine may
play a vital role in the management of inflammation."
A lack of sufficient taurine in a cat's diet can cause
blindness and a type of heart disease called dilated cardiomyopathy.
Since taurine is only found in
animal-based products, this is one reason why cats are obligate carnivores
- eating the flesh of another animal is the easiest and best way for a cat
to take in an adequate amount of taurine. However,
Plasma amino acid and whole blood taurine
concentrations in cats eating commercially prepared diets
(2009) Heinze CR, Larsen JA, Kass PH & Fascetti AJ American Journal
of Veterinary Research 70 p1374 found that there was little correlation
between the amount of protein in the diet and taurine levels in the cat's
blood.
Dietary rice bran decreases plasma and whole-blood
taurine in cats (2002)
Stratton-Phelps M, Backus RC, Rogers QR & Fascetti AJ Journal of Nutrition
132 pp1745S-47S mentions that studies have shown that "Cats fed canned
foods require a higher quantity of taurine than those fed dry foods to
prevent taurine deficiency resulting from alterations in the
bioavailability of taurine attributed to the effects of processing."
Feline nutrition update (2001) Biourge V
Presentation to the World Small
Animal Veterinary Association World Congress states "studies at Davis
found that dry extruded cat foods required about 1 g/kg diet, but canned
foods required up to 2.5 g/kg
If cats eat a higher fat or higher fibre canned diet,
they may also require additional taurine.
Dietary rice bran decreases plasma and whole-blood
taurine in cats (2002) Stratton-Phelps M, Backus
RC, Rogers QR & Fascetti AJ Journal of Nutrition 132 pp1745S-47S mentions
that "In addition to processing, both the fiber and fat content of canned
feline diets may affect taurine metabolism through an alteration of
intestinal bacteria and subsequent changes in the excretion of bile
acids."
Metabolic acidosis may affect taurine levels.
Acid-base, electrolytes and renal failure
(1999) Polzin DJ, Osborne CA, James K Supplement to
Compendium on Continuing Education for the Practising Veterinarian
21 11(K) states
"Studies on the effects of dietary acidification in cats have revealed
that chronic metabolic acidosis can cause negative potassium balance,
which may in turn promote...taurine depletion."
There is plenty of taurine in all cat foods, and an even higher level in
therapeutic kidney diets. However, some people do choose to give taurine
supplements to their CKD cats (a taurine supplement is usually essential
if you are feeding a homemade diet). Taurine is water soluble, so any
excess should be urinated out, but if you do supplement taurine, check
with your vet first —
Accumulation of taurine in patients with renal
failure (2002) Suliman ME, Bárány P, Divino
Filho JC, Lindholm B & Bergström J Nephrology Dialysis Transplantation
17(3) found that some human CKD patients given taurine supplements
complained of feeling dizzy, and tests showed that their taurine levels
were far in excess of normal following supplementation. Unlike cats, the
human body can produce its own taurine, so this might be a factor in the
side effects seen in this study. I don't know if there would be a similar
risk with cats, but please do not supplement taurine without your vet's
approval.
Arginine is important for insulin production in cats, and is
also necessary to convert ammonia into urea, a role so important that a
cat fed a diet deficient in arginine will develop high ammonia levels and
may die.
Some highlights in elucidating the peculiar
nutritional needs of cats (2007) Morris JG & Rogers QR Nestle
Purina 2007 Nutrition Forum
Focus on Felines Proceedings explains that severe problems relating to a lack of arginine
occurred within less than a day, with one cat dying.
Arginine is also used to make nitrous oxide in the
kidneys. It is thought that nitrous oxide plays a critical role in
regulating blood flow through the kidneys, and it is known that the amount
of blood flowing through the kidneys can affect kidney function.
L-arginine levels are often very low in CKD cats,
so it is possible that supplementing this might
increase nitrous oxide levels and thus help kidney function.
Nitric acid deficiency in chronic kidney disease (2008) Baylis C
American Journal of Physiology &
Renal Physiology 294(1) ppF1-9 explains more about this and states that
restoring nitrous oxide production may slow the progression of kidney
disease.
Role of L-arginine in the pathogenesis
and treatment of renal disease
(2004) Cherla G and Jaimes EA Journal of Nutrition 134 pp2801S-6S found
that l-arginine supplementation may be helpful or harmful in CKD. It
appears to be detrimental in cases of
glomerulonephritis.
I would not supplement l-arginine without your vet's
approval.
This is an amino acid which encourages the natural
production of BMP-7, which may help the kidneys regenerate. Apparently
studies are in hand for human CKD patients with this amino acid but I
don't know anybody who has used it in a cat. Do not use it without
checking with your vet first.
If your cat is eating a therapeutic kidney diet, in principle
additional vitamins should not be necessary, since suitable extra vitamins
are added to these foods. However, if your cat is not eating these foods,
additional vitamins may be necessary.
Vitamin B is helpful for most CKD cats regardless of
whether and what they are eating, and is particularly important for cats who
are anaemic.
Do not give vitamins to your cat without your vet's
approval because excess vitamin intake can be very dangerous.
This vitamin is fat soluble, and is stored in the
body rather than excreted. For this reason, there is a risk of toxicity
when supplementing it.
Hypervitaminosis A-induced hepatic fibrosis in a cat
(2014) Guerra JM, Daniel AG, Aloia TP, de Siqueira A, Fukushima AR,
Simões DM, Reche-Júior A & Cogliati B Journal of Feline Medicine
& Surgery 16(3) pp243-8 states "the cat is particularly
susceptible to chronic vitamin A toxicity." Vitamin A also promotes
calcification,
which is a risk with CKD cats because they have a tendency towards
calcification anyway.
In any event, a vitamin A deficiency is extremely rare, so it is highly
unlikely that your cat requires supplementation of any kind. For this
reason care should be taken when considering the use of multi-vitamin
tablets, which may contain vitamin A.
Although vitamin B is commonly referred to as if it
were a single vitamin, there are actually a number of B vitamins. These
are essential vitamins, which means that they cannot be manufactured in
the cat's body, so must be obtained from external sources (i.e. from food or a
supplement).
B vitamins are water-soluble, so are often lacking in
CKD cats, who lose much of their vitamin B through the excess urination
commonly seen in CKD cats. Cats who are
not eating much will also probably not be taking in enough B vitamins.
Pharmacological appetite stimulation: rational choices
in the inappetent cat (2014)
Agnew W & Korman R Journal of Feline Medicine & Surgery 16(9)
pp749-56 says "Cats have a higher requirement for some B vitamins when compared with dogs. Experimental depletion of B vitamins results in anorexia in other species. Supplementation with B vitamins may prevent
this occurring, although no evidence exists to confirm this. Still,
provision of B vitamins is simple and should be considered in all inappetent
cats."
B vitamins are so important for CKD cats that there is
a separate page about them
here.
I sometimes hear from people who are interested in
using large doses of vitamin C in their cats but this is not advisable.
The A-B-Cs of vitamin C
(2018) Nutrition Service at Cummings Veterinary
Medical Center at Tufts University states that giving too much vitamin C
makes it a pro-oxidant, promoting damage to cells rather than healing.